skip to content


Dear Uncle Ezra
 
 
Advanced
Uncle Ezra is on vacation
 

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 1 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Unc,
I have a few questions about citizenship.   I was reading the inside of my passport, and it says that one can renounce one's citizenship by going to a consular office and doing so.  If one doesn't become a citizen of another country, and also renounces their citizenship to their original country, what is their citizenship status?  Are they still able to travel internationally? The second question deals with the status of native americans, such as the Haudenasaunee (Iroquois).  As I understand it, they have their own passports, and can travel internationally with them.  Are they also dual citizens of the U.S.?  Do most countries recognize them as sovereign nations?  If not, and one does present a Haudenasaunee passport, what happens? Thanks

Dear reading passport,

This is a political world, of borders and laws, and the thought of renouncing citizenship is a dangerous one if you want to travel.  The Customs checks are rigorous, and abnormalities would cause, at the very least, a long hold-up while proper authorities are called to deal with the unusual situation.  You would also need to consider employment restrictions.

I have consulted with the ISSO and a prominent immigration authority and both agree that these are not simple questions. The best way to get definitive information would be to consult with an immigration attorney, which would entail a fee because the attorney would need to do some research.  The decision to renounce one's citizenship is a very serious matter and should not be taken lightly. It is difficult to renounce US citizenship these days, as you have to formally and voluntarily renounce your citizenship for it to be effective.

Haudenosaunee (or Iroquois) peoples are a political confederacy of six nations that predate the settlement of the Northeast by European peoples that became Americans. As pre-contact nations, contemporary Haudenosaunee issue their own passport to enable travel from their territories into foreign nation-states. These passports are issued by traditional government and have been recognized by some foreign countries, but not all. In order to get an Iroquois passport one must have a clan, transmitted through their mother's line and must be known to their clan mother, who will support or deny their request for a passport. Because these passports are not recognized by all nation-states, Haudenosaunee citizens may not be able to travel with the ease that they might were they to use an American or Canadian passport. Nonetheless, they make their decision to travel with their passport knowing this and recognize the passport as an exercise of their sovereignty and independence from the US and Canada.

Haudenosaunee people may also, based on their place of birth, obtain US or Canadian passports. Some chose to do this for the ease of travel that it enables. One must keep in mind, however, that as people that were and still are configured as nations and as a political Confederacy that pre-dates the settlement of North America, the use of a passport is a very meaningful act for Iroqouis people.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 2 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
Could you give us a recommendation of 3 good books to read about how to be students, and yet teachers at the same time, ethically? A very loyal graduate student niece!

Dear student/teacher,

There are many ethical issues to consider when you have a position of power over someone else in your workplace.  Essentially, a subordinate may not feel they can stand up for themselves against you without jeopardizing their job. Good boundaries are the key to ethical relations.  Keep work as work, and keep your personal life contained so the two don't contaminate one another.

The pamphlet "Guide to Graduate Study" is available at the Graduate School, and has a policy section including "Romantic and Sexual Relationships between Students and Persons in Authority."

A TA can have students to her house for a dinner to celebrate the end of the term, but if a single student stays over, and then the TA grades that student's paper the next day, there could be a conflict of interest.   Best to wait a few days until the grading is in, then consider next steps in a relationship.  If the student returns and this person is again the TA, the TA may ask to switch assignments, or ask someone else to do evaluations of her personal friend. 

Next, communicate.  Any questionable situations should be brought to the attention of a supervisor before "anything happens."  Always think about possible consequences, and let those who are more experienced help you see different perspectives.

Carol Gilligan's In a different voice talks about how ethical decision-making of males and females differ. 
Daryl Bem's Beliefs, attitudes and human affairs (1970) is a classic. 
Bloom's The Paradox of helping
Feldman and Newcomb's The impact of college on students, and
Fletcher's Situation Ethics: The new Morality (1966) may help.  
An article of interest is Glaser and Thorpe, 1986, "Unethical intimacy: a survey of sexual contact and advances between psychology educators and female graduate students", American Psychologist, 41 42-51. 

This book may also be of interest: Ethics and college student life : a case study approach by Kenneth A. Strike and Pamela A. Moss, in Olin.

If your concerns are in the area of time management, look for some generic workplace books.  Otherwise, these are good topics for a dissertation!

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 3 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

DUE,
why is upson B14 sooo cold? Can they raise the temp a bit so that we can pay attention and not freeze?

Dear cold,

Go to the facilities website  http://www.fm.cornell.edu/cs
and fill out a customer service form so they will be aware of the trouble.  Or you can call 255-5322 and ask them what the thermostat is set at and to please check it.  I have passed your concern on to the building manager also. Wishing you warmth.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle:
Last year, I wrote a letter to you (on Nov. 1st or so) complaining about Christmas coming earlier and earlier each year. I'd just like to point out that Target has their Christmas decorations up already again this year. In fact, they appeared around Oct 1st, which would be nearly THREE MONTHS early! This really needs to be stopped. I'm encouraging everybody to write letters to Target to protest. Bah, Humbug.

Dear Humbug,

I noticed Wegman's has their xmas stuff up too.  They're really missing out on the Halloween fun. Trick or Treat? I imagine someone in the main office has done the numbers and made the decision based on bottom line sales. The way they see it, people vote with their feet.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 5 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle,
sometimes when i go to a nice restaurant and order espresso after the meal it comes with a peace of lemon peel, why is that??? and they only give it to you with espresso, not other kinds of coffee! it's been bothering me for some time, since i feel that this is probably some kind of sophisticated custom and it makes me feel uncultured, so i think i should finally ask you and get over it. and here's a more serious question: i've graduated and now i'm trying to apply for a health insurance. i got a letter from them, saying that i'm denied the insurance because of "minor height/weight variation"!! and what do they mean by that?? i'm allowed to reapply and to explain this "medical condition" as they put it. but i have no idea what to write... i mean i'm skinny but i never had any medical problems associated with it. in fact all my friends envy me - i can eat anything  i want without getting fat. this is just too weird. what do you think? Thanks!

Dear cultured,

It's not the ultimate pleasure of the combination of taste sensations. The oil in the peel blocks the bitterness of overroasted espresso. It is not an Italian custom at all, but one story says American soldiers in Italy during WWII could only get espresso to drink for their coffee, and, not being used to its bitterness, they discovered that a small lemon peel cut down the strong taste. Espresso Romano, now refers to espresso served with lemon. Some say it's a throwback from a time when bars didn't sanitize cups properly, so the lemon peel could be rubbed on the edge of a coffee cup. Some people do like the added taste.

If you're looking for a taste as well as aromatic treat, try Turkish coffee, one of the oldest ways of preparing coffee, using a few cardamom beans ground with the coffee beans. Ask a friend to explore this taste treat with you.  Wishing you a cozy coffee clatch.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 6 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Deaer Uncle Ezra,
Is it possible for two children in the same family to have Aspergers Syndrome?  If the older child is diagnosed with the condition would it be likely for the younger child to unknowingly mimick the symptoms of the older child, using him as an example of how to behave?  Is there something in family genetics that would cause both kids to go through this difficult condition?  

Dear concerned,

Modeling, the process whereby we learn by observing and copying behavior, is a powerful influence on human (and primate) behavior, and you are astute in imagining how a non-affected sibling could superficially appear to have some symptoms of concern. However, as with any diagnosable syndromes, it is the severity and chronicity of the symptoms that can help to define whether a person is enacting or actually affected.

Asperger Syndrome (AS) is a neurobiological disorder named for a Viennese physician, Hans Asperger, who in 1944 published a paper which described a pattern of behaviors in several young boys who had normal intelligence and language development, but who also exhibited autistic-like behaviors and marked deficiencies in social and communication skills. In spite of the publication of his paper in the 1940's, it wasn't until 1994 that Asperger Syndrome was added to the official psychiatric diagnostic manual, DSM IV, and only in the past few years has AS been recognized by professionals and parents.  See http://www.udel.edu/bkirby/asperger/ .

There is some controversy around how AS relates to a larger category of autistic disorder. An answer to your question is difficult because of variable expression of the disorder and diagnostic ambiguities. AS has nongenetic and genetic etiologies. Nongenetic causes are associated with disruption, usually prenatally, to the pattern of normal brain development, such as prenatal exposure to viral infection, hypothyroidism and other medical conditions in the mother, or maternal drug use (Davis, Fennoy, and Laraque, in 1992, studied 70 mothers who used cocaine or engaged in poly-drug abuse during pregnancy. In this sample, 11.4% of these women gave birth to autistic children and 94% of the children born showed a pattern of delayed language development.)  Teratogens such as environmental toxins have also been implicated as possible etiologic agents in autistic spectrum disorders.

Genetic causes arise from mutations in genes controlling brain development. Estimates for sibling frequency have ranged from 2-14.5 %, 50-150 times the frequency in the general population, depending on the sex of the child. This information is documented in Bloch-Rosen, Sally, April 1999, Asperger's Syndrome, High Functioning Autism, and Disorders of the Autistic Continuum, http://www.aspergersyndrome.com/Paper040899.doc.

It is important for us all to understand how such mental health disorders affect a person's life, and to respond to these persons with compassion and friendliness.  Persons with mental health disorders are often the targets of bullying and harassment, and of stigmatized attitudes that increase their suffering. My heart goes out to the family you may be wondering about.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 7 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Ezra,
I'm a guy and ever since I moved into the dorms I have stopped masturbating. Not to say that I've gone celibate (I had an intimate encounter with a female a little while ago), just that with the amount of work I have to do and the lack of privacy I just don't have the chance to. It's not that I'm longing for it, I feel totally fine, I guess I'm just wondering if its healthy (physically and psychologically) to stop.

Dear feeling fine,

Not to worry. You seem have a remarkably healthy attitude toward self pleasuring. It's no surprise that with everything Cornell students have to do, they find themselves having to limit certain previously enjoyed activities. Sometimes that means reduced TV watching, sometimes less reading novels for pleasure, and in your case it's masturbating. Your energies are being directed in other ways, towards studying and extracurricular activities. While masturbation may provide a sense of relaxation, release and enjoyment, there are no unhealthy side effects that will result from your taking some time off from "solo sex". And it can be a healthy adaptation to the less private conditions you find yourself in.

Rest assured that your health will be maintained and when the sexual urges return, you should feel free to engage in your pleasures again.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 8 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
When will the Spring 2003 Course Time & Room roster be available?

Dear Student,

The Spring 2004 Course and Time roster (times, courses only) is available online now, go to Courses, Classes and Exams under CUInfo (http://cuinfo.cornell.edu/Academic/Class.html).  Exam information is also up on this link.  The room roster for those courses will first appear in mid-December.  Paper copies of the course and room roster will also be available through your college shortly, but with so much information, consult the web for the most up-to-date listings.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 9 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

DUE:
In reposnse to the question about a good mechanic in Ithaca from the October 2 post....   Art Snyder in lansing is WONDERFUL!  If you can print his phone # it's 607-533-4394 or 533-4661.  I would highly reccomend him to anyone.  Not only is he fair, highly knowledgeable and friendly, he is a cornell alum.  I drive from Syracuse to have my car serviced by him, he's that good! Just beware that you might come home with an extra cat, as he and his wife Sandy serve as foster parents for many SPCA cats! Niece '00

Dear Niece '00,

I'm glad you've had a good experience, but of course, he is a Cornell alum!

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 10 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Friday Oct 3,
2003 Dear Uncle Ezra,
I am writing an intellectual biography of Barbara McClintock. Please tell curious that McClintock's addresses during her undergraduate years at Cornell can be found in the Cornell Directories for the years she attended as an undergraduate (1919 and 1923).  A recent article on McClintock's years at Cornell is in the August issue of GENETICS, volume 164, pages 1251-1260. Sincerely, A McClintock fan

Dear McClintock fan,

Thanks, and good luck with your writing project.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 11 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
How does one get put on academic probation in the Ag&LS school,what kinds of grades does it take?

Dear Student,

At the end of each semester, the Committee on Academic Achievement and Petitions reviews the records of those students who in any respect are failing to meet the academic requirements of the college or who persistently fail to attend classes.  For students not making satisfactory progress, the committee takes appropriate action, including, but not limited to, issuing warnings, placing students on probation, granting students leaves of absence, advising students to withdraw, or suspending or expelling students.

Specifically, the committee considers as possible cause for action failure to attend and participate in courses on a regular basis or, at the end of the semester, failure to attain one or more of the following:
-semester/term average of at least 2.0*
-cumulative GPA of at least 2.0*
-satisfactory completion of 12 or more credits per semester
-reasonable progress toward completion of distribution requirements
-appropriate completion of college and University requirements
*For those students matriculation 8/01 or later.  Requirements are 1.70 for those who matriculated prior to 8/01

In general terms, regular participation in course work with academic loads at a level sufficient to assure graduation within eight semesters and grades averaging C (2.0) or higher are evidence of satisfactory progress and good academic standing.

There is no exact formula or cut-off for the committee placing a student on probation.  Lisa Ryan and Bonnie Shelley of the Counseling and Advising Office work with the Academic Achievement and Petitions Committee, and work with students with academic and personal concerns.  They'd be glad to meet with individual students to review your record and address your current concerns.  They're open Monday-Thursdays 8-5, Fridays 8-4, and are located in 140 Roberts Hall.  You may call the office at 254-5386 to set up an appointment at a convenient time.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 12 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
What is a guaranteed transfer? What does this mean?

Dear Student,

A small number of students who apply to Cornell University as freshman are offered a guarantee of transfer option. It simply states that although we are unable to offer them admission as a freshman, we would like to guarantee their admission as a transfer student. These students are then given fairly clear guidelines about what they need to do in order fulfill the requirements (usually they must achieve a certain g.p.a. and complete certain courses). If students receive this option and are unclear about the guidelines, they should contact the Undergraduate Admissions Office. I hope this helps.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 13 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Hi Uncle Ezra,
I was just reading about the student who died a few days ago after falling into the gorge behind Rockledge.  This story hit very close to home for me and my family because my brother fell in the gorge around that area too about 4 years ago but, by some insane miracle, survived.  I believe the fence that the student jumped over was actually built because of my brother's fall.  I can only imagine the pain of the student's family now that my own family so narrowly missed.   My question is, how many people actually survive gorge falls?  There is a lot of publicity around gorge deaths but I don't know if there was any around my brother's accident.  I remember a number of deaths during my own time there but know only one other story of survival -the one involving the racoon.  Any help would be much appreciated.  The whole incident still haunts my family and I was wondering if my brother's survival was as rare as we think it is. Thanks so much, Kate    

Dear Kate,

I hope your brother is doing well now.  He's fortunate to have a caring family to share the emotional shock and help him in his recovery. We did try to increase the safety of areas where the gorge drops off so dangerously, and so we are also saddened that the fence was not able to provide the safety needed this month.

I asked our police chief if he had the figures you seek. He said he could recall very few survivors that have fallen from the top of the gorge and ended up at the very bottom in his thirty three years here.  Many survivors had their fall broken part way down and were rescued.  This also happens with our amateur rock climbers, off-trail hikers, etc.  These cases are recorded as "Assist Ill/Injured" in the files, so it would be difficult to determine the exact circumstances inorder to give you the numbers.

Wishing you  well,

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 14 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
I was just reading your response to the memorial mausoleum located in Sage Hall, where Jennie McGraw Fiske is buried in the crypt underneath, as are her husband, Willard Fiske and her father, JohnMcGraw, Ezra Cornell and President White and families, Edmund Ezra Day and Deane W. Malott, the University's fifth and sixth presidents. I can understand why such notable historical figures such as the Fiske's, McGraw's, Ezra, and Andy are located there. But why are the former presidents, Day and Malott also buried in the crypt? Can other university presidents be buried there if their families wish?

Dear crytologist,

A precedent was set in A.D. White being interred there so that other Cornell presidents had the option. Incidentally, only a quarter of
Deane Malott's ashes are in the Sage crypt (one quarter is in Kansas, one in Hawaii, and one in Arizona!).  Frank Rhodes has said he intends to be buried there. "After all," he said, "all of my daughters were married here."

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 15 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Hi,
I'm a writer from Cornell's Daily Sun and was wondering if I would be able to ask whoever is responsible a few questions about who runs this program, anything you would like the cornell student population to know about what you do, some history and interesting facts about your program and so on. Would you be willing to have such an interview? Would I be able to e-mail you these questions? Matthew

Dear Sun Reporter,

Thank you for your article of October 7.  I hope you enjoyed researching "Dear Uncle Ezra" and that you learned a lot about our history and the way we try to extend the heart and soul of Cornell.  You are one of "us".

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 16 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
Regarding Q15 of 7 October 2003 on the smell from the radiator:  In an old house the radiator may not be heated by hot water but by steam.  In single pipe steam systems the condensed steam (water) runs back down the same pipe that it came up in rather than returning by another pipe.  As the steam first fills the system on a furnace cycle (controlled by the thermostat), the residual cool air is pushed out a vent on the radiator.  This is another source of odd-smelling air when the system is first turned on in the fall in addition to the heating of dust and stuff on the radiator surfaces.  I grew up in such a house on Eddy Street.  Balancing the vents on all the radiators so that the house heated evenly was a juggling act for my father, exchanging faster for slower vents until everyone was happy. A townie

Dear townie,

Thanks for your knowledge.  It would be a good idea, to keep indoor air quality high, to open widows when you first turn furnaces on, and let those first dusty fumes out the window before battening down the hatches for real.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 17 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
Last spring, I signed a contract for housing in the Gothics.  We were informed that the noise pollution from construction would be limited to the hours of 8am and 5pm on the weekdays and fewer hours over weekends and study weeks.  By signing the contract, we were essentially waiving our right to complain about noise pollution outside our homes during those hours. However, the construction this fall has frequently been starting before 8am (as early as 7am weekdays and weekends) and going past 5pm (as late as 11pm weekdays and weekends.)  Is there something students can do to have our housing contracts honored?  (My RHD and the Construction Project Manager have responded with "just move," even though open West Campus rooms are limited to other construction zones.)  And why do we still have quiet hours while construction is outside our windows?  Or will quiet hours finally by respected come study week?  Thanks! ~Very sleepy and avoiding my home

Dear Very sleepy and avoiding my home,

Our project manager has an entire job running apologies, and offers these: Once again apologies for disruption to this student. I wish we could make this all go away but we are faced with a  challenging scheduled projected opening in August 04. Perhaps some explanations are in order:

Officially contractors may not start work until 8AM. However, workers do arrive before 8AM and by opening tool boxes, starting the crane, closing truck doors, etc. they do make some low level noise. We are attempting to minimize this by meeting with the contractors' management,  forepersons and by  "patrolling" the site before 8AM to enforce compliance. Unfortunately we probably cannot eliminate noise altogether before 8AM but we are trying hard.

To have any chance of making the August 04 opening we must work the weekends. This was not planned even though we knew sooner or later some trades would get behind and have to accelerate by working Saturdays and/or Sundays. The late deliveries of the precast wall sections you see being erected by crane forced the weekend work to occur. As you may imagine it is very expensive to pay workers to work weekends but we really have no choice. We have asked the contractors (and there was good compliance last weekend) to not conduct loud work operations prior to 9AM on the weekends. This was a small concession to the students, but required significant effort on the part of the contractors and workers to do "quiet work" for the first hour.

From time to time work has gone on beyond dark- even until midnight. The concrete flooring planks being set in place by cranes receive a 2" topping of concrete. That concrete is poured from trucks early  in the morning (not before 8AM!), and depending on temperatures and other factors may require 8 -16 hours to take its initial set. Once set, gasoline driven machines with steel trowel blades are used to "finish" the topping to a smooth finish. This is the noise the students have heard late at night. Unfortunately this is a weather/temperature dependent operation- and once the concrete is placed there is no choice but to wait until the finishing work can be completed- thus the very late hours due to the cooler/cold temperatures of late. We have asked the contractors to pour as many of the slabs as possible during fall break and over Thanksgiving when most students are away. But I don't think that this will completely eliminate the late nights and possible disruption to students. Perhaps if the student knows this is temporary and that we are trying to mitigate disruption it will seem more tolerable. (As an aside- we did not hear from students at Lottery last year that working after dark or late hours would be a problem to them).

About exam and study week. From December 8-20,
2003 and May 10-22, 2004 the hours of noisy construction work will be restricted to the period 9AM until dusk. The contractors are keenly aware of this contractual restriction and this will be strictly enforced by CU management.

You should continue to work with your RHD and the Housing Office about the moving issue.

Again, apologizies to this student for any disruption we've caused. I hope you have a quiet retreat for Fall Break.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 18 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
I feel very opressed by my roommates (I am in a forced triple).  So far, I switched beds and closets with one of them.  Whenever I write something on the white board on our door, it's erased in no time at all.  They talk loud when I'm napping, but they tell me to be quiet even though I am half as loud as them being quiet.  They are such slobs that their garbage is flowing out of their cans and they throw their garbage in my can so that they don't have to clean theirs out for a little longer.  They ignore me almost completely in my room.  They forbid me from bringing my boyfriend over.  They blast their music to the point the whole suite is being bothered by the noise, and when I turn the volume up to their level, they tell me to turn mine off or use earphones so that they can listen to their music.   One thing that made me write to you today is because there was a big bug (for the third time since we came here.  Our screen is ripped and facilities didn't fix it yet even though I wrote it down on the blue evaluation sheet) in our room.  I asked them if they can kill the bug, but they completely ignored me.  I knew that they were no better than me in dealing with bugs and killing them, so I had a friend come over and kill it.  Then one of them said, "Would you mind?  We are trying to do some work here."  They would have gone beserk if the bug was within 5 feet from them, but unfortunately, it was near my desk, not theirs, so they couldn't care less.   I'm trying to be a good roomie, as much as possible.  But it has come to the point where I cannot deal with their self centeredness and carelessness of others anymore.   It is not only me who is annoyed by these two people.  Everyone who is in or has a room near our suite is annoyed by their loud music and yelling in middle of the night while they are susceptible to any kind of noise from outside when they are actually working.  I have great friendships with more than half of the floor and almost all of them are annoyed by my roommates.   I'm not sure if I should switch rooms, because I have great friends here, and even if I moved out, it does not end the misery my friends on my floor has to deal with for another nine months.  I am thinking of signing up to become an RA next year, so I am interested in what you think is the best solution for this problem.  What do you think, uncle? Your Opressed Niece

Dear Oppressed,

This situation does sound unbearable.  Have you talked to your RA, or RHD?  They deal with rommate problems and will have suggestions for you. There must be some regulations about noise   If they can't help you work things out, you and your roommates could go to mediation. Of course, this may not make for the most pleasant living conditions, but what have you got to lose? There just comes a point when you've bent as far as you can, and it sound like you've done too much accommodating others' needs -- now its time to take care of yourself. 

If it does come to you having to move, try to think positively, and consider it an opportunity to make new friends and improve your living situation in order to do better school work, get more sleep, feel better about yourself and the world you create around you.  I wish you the best.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 19 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

Dear Uncle Ezra,
        I just asked Professor Maas this question because it involves mind control with regards to a certain group on campus, but I would like to know your opinion too:  Just two weeks ago my girlfriend started acting really strange, and wanted to break up with me quite suddenly.  She had been talking about Quill and Dagger for a while, but finally a week after she told me not to get in touch with her at all, she let me know that she had joined the society.  In a bizarre twist, she had also cut her hair, bought all new clothes, and accused me of things that were not apparent in our relationship.   We had been best friends who shared everything, and now she won't even contact me.  I realized that having me as a best friend (especially a boyfriend) was a hindrance to her oath of secrecy taken with the group.  I am very open and communicative, and it became clear to her that being a friend to me and staying in the group would force her to lie too much to me to maintain her secrecy.  So she chose the group over me; it hurts.         I don't think such a group is illegal, but I can imagine that such a secrecy can be very unhealthy to its members, especially later on in life.  In the past, I would have been more open minded and said that such group has their own right to make whatever rules they want, but now it has come close to home and hurt me deeply.  The society may do good things overall, but their deception and psychological pressure shows lack of integrity and honesty.  I would like to know what should be done about this, and how to make sure future generations of Cornellians are not hurt by Quill and Dagger (either directly by the group's mind control, or indirectly by loosing a friend to it).         Thanks so much. Sincerely, A Concerned Nephew

Dear Concerned Nephew,

I'm sorry about these changes you've been caught in.  Your friend has taken some turns in her life, and your own life is on a different road. From what you tell me, I would guess that she has made a lot of changes in her life, the group being only a part of that.  I don't think it's as simple as her choosing the group over you.  Such a group, although offering friendship and belonging, does not fill the intimacy needs of a relationship. However, people may feel the need to take a break from intimate relationships while they immerse themselves in a group identity for a while.

Information voids invite imaginations.  Where you don't know the facts, you start to form your own hypotheses about what might be happening. Good communication is good relationship. The suddenness with which you were confronted by these accusations makes me think that perhaps there were some conversations that needed to happen long before the final door was closed.  Sometimes we just don't know that these issues need to be discussed so thoroughly, we assume things are "good enough" and we keep on keeping on, not realizing things are drifting apart.  It is only through experiences like this that we learn to tune in our radar a little more, and to say a little more about what we're sensing.

You raise an interesting point about the effects of secrecy on relationships outside the inner circle.  These problems are faced by partners and family members of undercover cops, CIA agents, and even counselors who must keep confidences and not share their work at home. The integrity and honesty gets divided, the person is trustworthy on the job, and on the homefront they trust others to trust that they are not deliberately deceiving.

I'm sorry for your hurt.  You are a sensitive person, and I hope you can find a relationship with someone who reciprocates your caring.

Uncle Ezra   


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 20 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

hi uncle,
i am having a really hard time dealing with someone ELSE's depression.  it is making me depressed.  my long distance boyfriend is very lonely in grad school and seems to always feel like he has few friends.  its not like i am out partying it up every night, but he seems to be sad every single day and night.  i often mistake his reticence for coldness, and also think it's aimed at me (i realize it usually is not, but its hard to remember this).  anwyay i am super distracted becuase i am always worrying about him.  he wont go talk to a therapist.  so i listen, but it hurts me to see him hurt.  and i cant concentrate.  and, at times, he seriously pushes me away so much (when he is really feeling bad and dependent, he sort of becomes mean) that sometimes i think he is just using me for when he feels bad... although i do know that it's possible that his reaction is all part of his depression... i dont know, i am just confused.

Dear confused,

Being a friend or family member of someone who is depressed can be challenging. You really don't know how much to respond, or how much to believe them when they say "go away."  Sometimes you can say, "that's just the depression talking," but you can't help feeling hurt and abandoned when your own needs are unattended to.

At some point, you must attend to your needs, and find relationships that offer you reciprocity and help you to grow personally.  You can model this behavior for your boyfriend, if he needs encouragement to find some social interaction where he is.  Although he may not be a social butterfly, there are often grad student gatherings where it's easy to meet interesting people and network, too. You don't want to be his only source for everything multiple relationships provide.

If your friend is depressed and needing help, you can use some caring "I" statements to tell him how you feel, as you did in this letter. You feel neglected (the coldness) and hurt, distracted with worry, which you can't do anything about, since it's him and not you who is suffering. You feel used, and you'd like him to use some of his obvious ability to manage himself (he is in grad school, not an easy thing) and take care of himself better. If and when he does, you'll feel listened to, heard, cared about, and relieved. "I" statements keep you from blaming the other person, which keeps that person from being defensive. I hope you both feel better soon.

Uncle Ezra   

 
Copyright 2013 Cornell University