- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 1 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Uncle Ezra,
Why does Cornell take so many transfers? I have nothing against transfers, as a good portion of them go on to do great things, but it seems that Cornell accepts anyone with a 3.7+ from community colleges. I recently found out that Cornell even accepts 2nd semester junior transfers...now how is that fair? (they took more semesters at their previous school than they will at Cornell...)
Freshman admits have to go through all the weed out classes and compete for A's against all the over achievers who managed to get through the rigorous selection process during senior year, while transfers from "lesser" schools cruise through easy classes where their peers aren't really academically motivated and then come here with their GPA untouched and end up getting the same degree as us.
Not to mention that all the best houses on West are reserved for transfers, so people like me end up in collegetown cause of the lack of remaining spots.
I tabulated the overall transfer acceptance rate based on the published data, and got around a 24% (from what I remember). Not only is this higher than the freshman rate (which is ludicrous in itself), but it's also much higher than the transfer rates of peer schools/other ivies.
Bottom line: What does Cornell gain by accepting an inordinate amount of transfers?
(I know I'm going to get flamed quite a bit by offended people, but curiosity got the better of me)
Dear Jealous of Transfers,
Each of Cornell’s colleges and schools has specific policies and plans regarding the admission of transfer students. I doubt the numbers are higher than other peer institutions of equal size.
Transfer students are a crucial part of Cornell’s mission and founding. Cornell was founded as both the land grant university of New York State as well with the phrase “any student, any study” so inherent to our mission. I believe (as I am sure many do) that Cornell has a right and responsibility to accept transfer students as they are so integral to our founding and what we stand for. I would also guess that some of our colleges/schools feel that transfer students provide a wealth of knowledge and perhaps real world experience to the classroom that our non-transfer students don’t have.
Cornell carefully screens all of its applicants for admission to the university. To imply that transfer students coming to Cornell have come from “lesser” schools, are unable to do the work, and are from schools where students aren’t academically motivated is simply not true. Many of our transfer students come from both two and four year institutions (not that it should matter) and are incredibly successful at Cornell.
For many students, the cost of higher education is a significant burden to both families and individuals. By transferring, many students are able to take advange of in state scholarships at other colleges and university and are then able to graduate from Cornell in less debt. They also take the spaces opened up by students who graduate early or transfer out, and therefore are paying tuition for spots that would otherwise be empty. These empty spots would create a huge loss of revenue to the university and would cause your tuition to be increased even more that it is now.
As for the housing question, Cornell guarentees housing to all transfer students that apply by a specific date because the living/learning compontent of Cornell is something the university has decided all undergraduates should be able to take advantage of.
Finally, many of our greatest alums are transfer students. Our University President transferred during his undergraduate days. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 2 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DUE,
Can students work on the Dear Uncle Ezra website?
Dear Student,
Uncle Ezra sometimes sends questions to groups of students to get a student perspective on things...remember at over 200 years old, I don't always know about the latest fads or gadgets or styles or acceptable ways of doing things.
I am continually impressed by Cornell students; especially how brilliant, innovative and generous you are. Lately, it has been wonderful to hear how much you enjoy your courses, support each other and are working for a sustainable earth inhabited by people who care. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 3 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DUE
In one of my classes the TA took it upon himself to create two 1 hour "discussion sections" per week for the class. Although he did state that the "discussion sections" are optional but HIGHLY recommended and hugely to our advantage to attend, and I know he is trying to help us, but I must say that i do not feel comfortable with the situation. I for one cannot attend the proposed "Discussion sections" so that will only severely disadvantage my own, as well as any others that cannot attend, performance in the class. I think that if the registrar, or the department or whatever entity determined two 75-min lectures per week were sufficient for you to almost double that does not seem right or fair. Especially since it is unofficial and after the fact. What should I do?
Dear Student,
It does seem that the TA has done this in order to help, but it is easy to see how it can be a disadvantage for those who can't make it. You might let the TA know of your concerns and ask for a different time that you can attend.
You also might make use of office hours. Check with the professor. Maybe other TA's are also offering extra sections that you would be able to attend. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 4 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Uncle Ezra,
Is there a place on campus where I can make high (archival) quality prints of digital artwork? I would think the fine arts students would have such a facility..
Thanks!
Artsy-but-not-art-major
Dear Artsy,
Your Uncle assumes this digital artwork is something you’ve created yourself— and not someone else’s copyrighted stuff, right?
With that understanding, a convenient printer (an Epson 2880) loaded with archival pigment inks for all kinds of artsy paper is operated by the Cornell Library’s Digital Media Group. Their front office is temporarily camped in 175 Kroch (while the Olin Library renovation is underway) 9 a.m. to 5 p.m. weekdays. Cash or check is the accepted payment for their printing services, with a two-week turnaround time.
Your Uncle can vouch for the top-quality work of the Digital Media crew (although not as cheap as online commercial services) and also for an off-campus place called The Wordpro (410 E. Upland Rd., about a 15-minute hike from North Campus) where they produce luscious Giclée prints. You don’t have to be an art major to make art. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 5 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Uncle Ezra,
I will actually quote something that a concerned parent on a forum said about Cornell's marketing:
"As parent to senior who expressed interest in Cornell early Jr. yr and has stats to be a viable candidate, Cornell did NOTHING to market to him. When you come for a tour, they don't get your name and address, interests to make that possible. If you put yourself on their mailing list you get one, maybe two mailings - in a complete year whereas other schools, I have files that are 4 inches thick (maybe a bit too much)! I don't think Cornell can just sit back and think they can continue to just sit back on Ivy status and people will come to them. I have also asked on this forum, why Cornell vs. others (for my own understanding, not to bash it, but to make a good judgement come April) and got crickets. On other websites (c-*******), you hear repeatedly 'uncaring profs' 'large cutthroat classes' 'weed out students'. If you don't create positive vibes through marketing, the only noise you hear is the negative."
The question is...why doesn't Cornell advertise more? Marketing would obviously attract more applicants and slightly boost yield, so Cornell wouldn't have to accept as many students...boosting selectivity. Especially with all the bad publicity it got last year from the wave of suicides, it should've tried harder to send mailings/emails to prospective students (as can be seen by the nonexistent increase in apps this year).
I just don't understand the talks about building 2 new dorms to increase the student body. Instead of increasing selectivity, Cornell seems like it's trying to decrease it. Eventually, this IS going to affect public perception as well as lower ranks in the U.S. News and other publications. Now, Cornell might not want to play the rankings game like other peers, but the way I see it is, if it doesn't, consecutive drops in rank and perception is eventually going to decrease the quality of the student body, which will further decrease the rankings in a perpetual cycle until Cornell does something about this.
As a concerned student, I fear for the future of our school as it seems to be doing little to boost its image to high school juniors and seniors.
Dear Concerned Student,
Cornell is in the business of education and research and that's what Cornell spends its money on and it is what it does best. We are not in the business of littering people's mailboxes with paper. Not very sustainable, to say the least.
I hope that you are using the resources made available to you here to get the best education you can. What you learn while you are here will determine where you go in life and your happiness, not how Cornell is ranked. Cornell is spending its money on what is most important, your education. I hope you can appreciate that. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 6 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DUE,
I'm thinking about switching majors. Again. At one point, I remember being very passionate about my major, but now, I'm not so sure. I'm a junior now, so this seems like a big problem. There wouldn't be enough time to fulfill the requirements of some other major, if I want to graduate on time. If I want to stay an extra year, then financial aid becomes an issue. My plan right now is to finish the requirements for my current major, since I'm almost done with it. What should I do if I want to study something else? Get another BA or BS? Can I stay here? Would I have to do that at another institution? I already ruled out grad school as a possibility (the area I'm looking at requires a lot of undergraduate courses in the area to start a graduate program in that area).
Dear Wondering,
I always love hearing from people who love so many things; although I do know that it can make life difficult. Sounds like finishing the major you are in right now might be the way to go. You can always supplement that with individual courses here or at another university. Education is a lifelong adventure. You will learning in whatever field you enter.
A trip to the Cornell Career Center or talking to a career counselor or advisor in your college at Cornell may provide insight or options that you haven't thought of. Good luck on your journey and keep on learning. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 7 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Ezra,
How does the Cornell Graduate School look upon applicants with an undergraduate degree from Cornell? There are a bunch of upper-level classes in my department that I want to take but I will graduate before I can take them( I have had to retake some courses since I transfered to Cornell). I would love to spend more time at Cornell.
Dear Student,
Here is the scoop from the Graduate Studies Office at Cornell.
Graduate School isn’t designed to be a continuation of undergraduate education. By desire and design, the main objective of PhD programs and research masters at Cornell is not to have the student take more course work, but rather to have the student gain core competency and then make new discoveries to advance their field of study. Professional Masters, of which Cornell has a growing number, have a slightly different emphasis and additional course work is often part of the requirements for degree for those programs.
Although there is a centralized admissions process in the Graduate School for all fields, admissions to graduate programs at Cornell are actually handled at the field level, by faculty and admissions committees in the field. So I would advise the student to talk to the graduate faculty in the field, starting with the department chair or their undergrad advisor, to get both a sense of what types of degrees are offered in the field(s) of interest and what any particular fields “take” on Cornell undergrads might be.
Some professional masters like to recruit Cornell undergrads because they usually have close relationships with those peer faculty who act as references and they know a proven undergrad can survive the rigors of Cornell. Other fields want students who can bring new perspectives and experiences to the table and so look to students who have experiences away from the academe or, at the very least, in a different academic environment.
As an assistant dean of the Graduate School, I would say I find that students who have broader experience (work, gap year, other educational experiences) tend to have a better graduate school experience because of the break between undergrad and grad school, irrespective of where they get their undergrad degree. I am a firm advocate of the “gap” year, or decade, (teach for America, peace corps, study abroad) and actual employment before graduate school. It gives the student an opportunity to grow and mature into the graduate student mentality, rather than expecting a “ super senior” experience. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 8 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DUE,
How would I go about getting a job as a sabermetrician? Does such a job even exist?
Dear Sabermetrician-to-be,
The job market must be changing —if students are trying for occupations Your Uncle never heard of.
Luckily, Wikipedia defines sabermetrics as: “the analysis of baseball through objective evidence, especially baseball statistics that measure in-game activity rather than industry activity such as attendance. The term is derived from the acronym SABR, which stands for the Society for American Baseball Research.”
Even luckier, Cornell Baseball employs Scott Marsh, assistant coach and recruiting coordinator, who says:
“The metrics we use in helping to evaluate our players are On-base plus Slugging (OPS) and Runs Created. Our season is so short (40 games compared to 162 in MLB), and our players cycle through every four years, so it’s hard to apply some of the more complicated/detailed formulas for evaluation purposes.”
Adds Coach Marsh, who played a little professional ball before landing a job at Cornell:
“I’d recommend a background in applied mathematics or applied statistics. Then the more difficult task is getting one’s foot in the door in a major league organization. Most of the young guns being hired as GMs these days are disciples of Bill James. They tend to work their way up through the organization, beginning as an assistant to the General Manager. The problem is, there are so many people with an interest in getting these types of positions, the competition is extraordinary.”
Thanks, Scott, for that cautionary advice. You’re saying Cornell grads should have a Plan B or two? Kind of like Franklin W. Olin, Class of 1885 mechanical engineer? He once slugged a ball (hurled by a Toronto pro team pitcher) precisely 540 feet from home plate in the Arts Quad (where Cornell games were played in the early years). The only thing to stop Olin’s homer was the brick wall (providentially, not a stained glass window) of Sage Chapel.
Olin himself played pro ball in the summertime (his career average in the majors was .316) to earn tuition. During the school, the power-hitting second baseman (and crew rower, shot putter, and hammer thrower) repaired farm machinery to earn his room and board. Indeed, the bat Olin was swinging (in that legendary May 1, 1886, game against Toronto) had been carved from the wooden tongue of a farm wagon.
But instead of baseball, the patriarch (1860-1951) of the Olin family of Cornell grads (and generous philanthropists) forged a successful career in the munitions and chemicals business. These days if you try to hit a ball from the Arts Quad to Sage Chapel, you’ll have to get over a library named for son John M. Olin, Class of 1913 — where you can read more about sabermetrics. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 9 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Dear Uncle Ezra,
A lot of older alumni ask me if they still had chocolate chip cookies at WSH when I was a student. I don't remember any cookies and neither do any of my friends. When did they stop serving these cookies?
Dear Cookie Monster,
I guess cookies come and go. Today the Ivy Room, Okenshields and Cascadeli all have DELICIOUS chocolate chip cookies, large and small. Hopefully, you will have a chance to come back for a visit and sample these Cornell delicacies. Uncle Ezra - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Question 10 - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
DUE,
Are you allowed to turn on red in Ithaca?
Dear Driver,
You are allowed to turn on red anywhere in New York State except in New York City, where you probably don't want to drive at all! Uncle Ezra |